The False Choice Most Men Believe

Most men feel like they only have two options when relationships become difficult. They can either give in to keep the peace, or they can become stubborn and stop caring what anyone thinks. 

Neither approach works. 

One causes us to lose ourselves. The other causes us to lose the relationship. 

Adam Chose Connection Without Conviction

And many of us do the same. We do whatever is necessary to keep others happy, even if it means compromising who God has called us to be. 

For a moment, this relieves the pressure we feel. The conflict subsides. The tension eases. But the peace is only temporary. 

Over time, something inside us begins to die. Resentment grows. Responsibility erodes. We’re only faking the peace and eventually the cracks of this well-meaning deception begin to show, despite our best intentions otherwise.  

Moses offers a different example. 

Moses Stayed Connected Without Abdicating

Throughout Israel’s journey in the wilderness, Moses endured complaints, criticism, and resistance. The people grumbled. They questioned his leadership. At one point, even Miriam and Aaron challenged his authority. 

Yet Moses neither abandoned the people nor abandoned the mission God had given him. He remained engaged – listening, interceding, and caring deeply for those he led. 

At the same time, he refused to let their approval determine his obedience. Moses could listen to their complaints without allowing their complaints to dictate his path forward. 

And this is the challenge for us as well. 

Listening Is Not the Same as Surrendering

To stay connected means we listen, care, and seek to understand because the relationship matters. To abdicate means we surrender our responsibility and allow another person’s thoughts, feelings, or reactions to determine our choices. 

The two are not the same. 

Many men confuse listening with agreeing, understanding with surrender, and love with appeasement. 

We do well as a husband to listen to our wife when she is upset. Even in her frustration, she may be helping us see something we would have otherwise missed. 

But staying connected does not require us to merely appease her. Nor does it require defending ourselves. 

We can acknowledge her fears and concerns. We can take her perspective seriously. We can invite further conversation and continue seeking understanding. All the same, we can and must remain grounded in the convictions God has given us. 

This is not about winning an argument. It is about remaining obedient to God. 

And this is precisely where Adam and Saul failed. 

Both knew what God had asked of them. But both also faced pressure from people they cared about. And both abdicated their obedience in order to avoid the discomfort that faithfulness would have required. 

This reveals something important. 

Why Relational Discomfort Feels So Threatening

The issue is often less about the conflict itself and more about our ability to tolerate relational discomfort. There is no formula that will solve every disagreement we encounter. There is no script that guarantees everyone will understand our decisions. 

Our challenge is learning to remain grounded when others are disappointed with us. 

Can we tolerate misunderstanding and criticism? Can we tolerate the rise of fear, shame, and self-doubt without allowing them to control our decisions? Can we keep calm when everyone around us is losing their cool? 

That is where strength is tested.  

Staying connected in these moments is costly. It means enduring misunderstanding, disappointment, criticism, and sometimes anger without abandoning either the relationship or our convictions. 

It means remaining present and engaged without surrendering our responsibility. 

And that is why genuine leadership always requires sacrifice. 

Dr. Corey Carlisle

Licensed marriage and family therapist and certified sex therapist who helps Christian men overcome passivity, pornography struggles, shame, and disconnection so they can become grounded husbands, fathers, and leaders. Through counseling, writing, and men’s formation work, he helps men reclaim their masculine strength as a gift for God, their families, and the world. He practices in Suwanee, Georgia.

Leave a Reply